Pet Shop Boys have remixed Madonna's Sorry

Message

frenchpsbfan · #121 Post by **frenchpsbfan** » Thu 19 Jan 2006, 5:37 pm

it's a good one for me!

Debussy · #122 Post by **Debussy** » Thu 19 Jan 2006, 7:40 pm

Was I the only one who gets the irony in the lyric "I've heard it all before" ? it's far from innovative. Kinda reminds me of some of the Motiv8 mixes from years ago and a sound that I was dancing to in the early 90's.

I dont like it at all - its cheesy eurodisco pop that will sell by the truckloads.
As marketing it's essential - as music it's disposable.

diana · #123 Post by **diana** » Thu 19 Jan 2006, 8:03 pm

Debussy wrote:Was I the only one who gets the irony in the lyric "I've heard it all before" ? it's far from innovative. Kinda reminds me of some of the Motiv8 mixes from years ago and a sound that I was dancing to in the early 90's.

I dont like it at all - its cheesy eurodisco pop that will sell by the truckloads.
As marketing it's essential - as music it's disposable.

Hmmm, about the original, I hardly heard anything before that sounds so perfect!

shamelessbehave · Thu 19 Jan 2006, 8:34 pm

diana wrote:One person: "I´m sorry, I´m so sorry". The other: "I heard it all before, I heard it all before"

It could be a cynical Neil Tennant lyric.

This reminds me of another famous duo who sing and fight but absolutely different music: Pimpinela

delusions · #125 Post by **delusions** » Thu 19 Jan 2006, 11:14 pm

shamelessbehave wrote:
diana wrote:One person: "I´m sorry, I´m so sorry". The other: "I heard it all before, I heard it all before"

It could be a cynical Neil Tennant lyric.
This reminds me of another famous duo who sing and fight but absolutely different music: Pimpinela

What a imagination!

¯ §ómèWhèr€ ¯ · Fri 20 Jan 2006, 12:17 am

shamelessbehave wrote:Pimpinela

still exists that duo?

,

is a miracle

glennjridge · #127 Post by **glennjridge** » Fri 20 Jan 2006, 12:22 am

listening to this remix,I sometimes think these type of arrangements for neil and chris are onews they can do almost by default, its almost like going on autopilot or they are using a template when they work on a remix.

next time they do a remix, rather than do whats expected of them, ie add throbbing low end synth arps and bleeps I would rather have them do a beautiful slow version of the song they are working on.

thats why I think "where the streets have no name" wasnt all that well recieved musically. I felt a more stripped down slower version would have been far more stirring.

will_castano · #128 Post by **will_castano** » Sat 21 Jan 2006, 3:23 am

thats why I think "where the streets have no name" wasnt all that well recieved musically. I felt a more stripped down slower version would have been far more stirring.

I don't agree. The whole shock value of PSB's Where The Streets was based around the fact that someone had defaced a U2 song by re-recording with a tinny hi-NRG beat and whizzing it into super-camp stratosphere with Can't Take My Eyes. The disco-fied rock thing happens a lot now, but at the time it was subversive & sacrilegious & therefore brilliant. Slow & stirring wouldn't have made anywhere near as strong a statement. The original was slow & stirring anyway.

But I agree about Sorry. Predictable and underwhelming.

DJCulture · #129 Post by **DJCulture** » Sat 21 Jan 2006, 7:09 pm

The original version is a tough act to follow. I wasn't too keen on the PSB version after the first couple of listens, but it's growing on me now. It's not that bad.

Kandu · #130 Post by **Kandu** » Sat 21 Jan 2006, 10:05 pm

diana wrote:One person: "I´m sorry, I´m so sorry". The other: "I heard it all before, I heard it all before"

It could be a cynical Neil Tennant lyric.

Actually, both of them are saying sorry!

lucienchardon · #131 Post by **lucienchardon** » Sat 21 Jan 2006, 11:15 pm

Whose vocoderized voice is that around 0:47 seconds? Neil? Madonna? Chris?

diana · #132 Post by **diana** » Sun 22 Jan 2006, 1:28 pm

lucienchardon wrote:Whose vocoderized voice is that around 0:47 seconds? Neil? Madonna? Chris?

I think that is the computer talking.

gareth · #133 Post by **gareth** » Sun 22 Jan 2006, 4:49 pm

gareth wrote:Sounds like Mr Lowe via a vocoder near the start - love it.

lucienchardon · #134 Post by **lucienchardon** » Sun 22 Jan 2006, 10:31 pm

gareth wrote:
gareth wrote:Sounds like Mr Lowe via a vocoder near the start - love it.

Sorry, I missed your original post. When I first heard it I thought it was Chris too. But you never know with a vocoder/computer.

Oznerol · #135 Post by **Oznerol** » Mon 23 Jan 2006, 4:57 am

shamelessbehave wrote:
diana wrote:One person: "I´m sorry, I´m so sorry". The other: "I heard it all before, I heard it all before"

It could be a cynical Neil Tennant lyric.
This reminds me of another famous duo who sing and fight but absolutely different music: Pimpinela

Oh my God!!!!!!! This is the latest name I ever expected to see mentioned by somebody on this forum!!!!!! I didn´t know Pimpinela was known outside Argentina!!! This is so weird

!! (and yes, they´re still making records...

)