Hits and MISSES

Message

zazou · #1 Post by **zazou** » Sat 27 May 2006, 10:16 pm

What do you think that are the great misses of the PSB?

For me, it has to be C2H and the last 2 albums before Fundamental. Damn guitar fling.

Vicki · #2 Post by **Vicki** » Sat 27 May 2006, 10:25 pm

I can't call any of mentioned by you albums misses. They all are great and I'm really proud of the Boys for making such beautiful albums like C2H, Nightlife and Release.

zazou · #3 Post by **zazou** » Sat 27 May 2006, 10:30 pm

They are great, I enjoy listening but not top notch à la Behaviour, Very, Please or Actually.

Vicki · #4 Post by **Vicki** » Sat 27 May 2006, 10:39 pm

zazou wrote:They are great, I enjoy listening but not top notch à la Behaviour, Very, Please or Actually.

If you look at the sales, yes, but if you just close your eyes and listen to them, they are masterpieces, arent' they?

zazou · #5 Post by **zazou** » Sat 27 May 2006, 10:45 pm

Vicki wrote:
zazou wrote:They are great, I enjoy listening but not top notch à la Behaviour, Very, Please or Actually.
If you look at the sales, yes, but if you just close your eyes and listen to them, they are masterpieces, arent' they?

Lol, PSB's music is above everything else. I rate music as Gold, Silver and Bronze. PSB is Diamonds so no contest there.

Vicki · #6 Post by **Vicki** » Sat 27 May 2006, 11:02 pm

zazou wrote:
Vicki wrote:
zazou wrote:They are great, I enjoy listening but not top notch à la Behaviour, Very, Please or Actually.
If you look at the sales, yes, but if you just close your eyes and listen to them, they are masterpieces, arent' they?
Lol, PSB's music is above everything else. I rate music as Gold, Silver and Bronze. PSB is Diamonds so no contest there.

Agree

Ewok · #7 Post by **Ewok** » Sat 27 May 2006, 11:02 pm

C2H is a damn good record - unfortunately without a single. Production and songwriting surely are superior to PLEASE. RELEASE was different, but still a good record and it actually features not more guitars than FUNDAMENTAL.

Their mistake was New York City Boy.

PSBehaviour · #8 Post by **PSBehaviour** » Sat 27 May 2006, 11:04 pm

Missed Hits:
Positive role model
Home
Somebody else's business

I still believe that D3 is a great album if u leave the Thee Radical and Superchumbo shit mixes out of it.

zazou · #9 Post by **zazou** » Sat 27 May 2006, 11:08 pm

PSBehaviour wrote:Missed Hits:
Positive role model
Home
Somebody else's business...

Just add Sexy northerner and Always to that list and I'll have a totally different view

shaunh7 · #10 Post by **shaunh7** » Sun 28 May 2006, 12:44 am

Miss for me is 'before', I tried so hard to like it

#11 Post by **Drico One** » Sun 28 May 2006, 12:49 am

Closer To Heaven was a disaster. The songwriting for that project produced one track that could stand against any in their canon, but the subsequent production massacred the exquisitely fragile For All Of Us demo. That summed up the whole affair in microcosm for me. What started out as a potential high collapsed in a welter of stereotypical guff.

Drico.

joeythecat · #12 Post by **joeythecat** » Sun 28 May 2006, 12:04 pm

Drico One wrote:Closer To Heaven was a disaster. The songwriting for that project produced one track that could stand against any in their canon, but the subsequent production massacred the exquisitely fragile For All Of Us demo. That summed up the whole affair in microcosm for me. What started out as a potential high collapsed in a welter of stereotypical guff.

Drico.

Well Said, as a project, Closer To Heaven went to Hell. It was a big stereotype without any kind of foil to counteract the cliché-ridden storyline. It also had the poor effect of seeping its musical influence or distraction into three PSB releases. “For All Of Us” wasn't all that bad in it's produced form and would not sound out of place on a soundtrack album... The true loss from demo to final product was Home/Here which became polished but without the original edge. Overall, the closer to heaven era is at best a curiosity to the songwriting process more than an enjoyable collection of music. On the other hand Battleship Potemkin was excellent and was needed for them to exorcise the show tune demons.

stussyboy · #13 Post by **stussyboy** » Sun 28 May 2006, 12:40 pm

Drico One wrote:Closer To Heaven was a disaster. The songwriting for that project produced one track that could stand against any in their canon, but the subsequent production massacred the exquisitely fragile For All Of Us demo. That summed up the whole affair in microcosm for me. What started out as a potential high collapsed in a welter of stereotypical guff.

Drico.

Rubbish. As a musical it was fantastic. It the protagonists were all straight, it would have been a massive success. Too many people cannot get past the fact that it is a "gay musical".

My Night, Something Special, FAOU and Call me old-fashioned all stand up to some of the best PSB material.

discotex · #14 Post by **discotex** » Sun 28 May 2006, 3:37 pm

Maybe PSB could prove to us how good C2H was by actually releasing some of the songs as finished demos with Neil's vocals, even as a bonus disc of some sort. There are some really amazing songs there that may never get their due. Respect what they were attempting, but lost some great tunes which should have been theirs.

#15 Post by **Drico One** » Sun 28 May 2006, 3:52 pm

stussyboy wrote:Rubbish. As a musical it was fantastic. It the protagonists were all straight, it would have been a massive success. Too many people cannot get past the fact that it is a "gay musical".

My Night, Something Special, FAOU and Call me old-fashioned all stand up to some of the best PSB material.

I'm sorry, but the sexuality of the protagonists has nothing to do with the derivative trash that was Closer To Heaven. The cliche-ridden, hackneyed storyline that reduced the characters to unsympathetic cardboard cutouts ensured the show closed almost before it had opened. The reviews - often written by gay men - were scathing. That told its own tale. This wasn't a "gay" musical. This was ridiculous, stereotypical ghettoising of the most demeaning kind.

Drico.