If you could erase something from PSB's carreer...

Message

DominoDancing · #46 Post by **DominoDancing** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 12:38 pm

The Nightlife era is probably the worst offender. I don't think there was enough good material for both the album and the musical. The production on the album is very boring. And, as mentioned above, New York City Boy was really, really bad and hurt their reputation more than Go West. I think both songs have a lot to do with the fact that (at least parts of) the public consider them to be nothing more than "some gay dance band", and New York city boy was not good enough of a song to make up for that.
To answer the question: I would delete Nightlife and the musical and replace it with an album of the best songs from both projects. And I'd burn every tape, hard drive etc. that contains a trace of New York city boy.

Radiophonic · #47 Post by **Radiophonic** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 12:43 pm

I dislike New York City Boy too. I would also dispose of Satuday Night Forever, which I class the same.

Ray · #48 Post by **Ray** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 3:25 pm

New York City Boy again. And I wish that I could somehow magically remove all traces of it from my collection as well. I think I only have more formats of I don't know what you want but I can't give it any more than of New York city boy. *sigh* And the worst thing is that I used to really, really like New York city boy.

dVTB · #49 Post by **dVTB** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 3:51 pm

New York city boy was the most recent PSB track (the single with Robbie Williams not counted) that received decent airplay on Dutch radio. I don't see why people dislike it so much.

Radiophonic · #50 Post by **Radiophonic** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 4:04 pm

dVTB wrote:New York city boy was the most recent PSB track (the single with Robbie Williams not counted) that received decent airplay on Dutch radio. I don't see why people dislike it so much.

"You'll never have a bored day" for one thing.

joshua76it · #51 Post by **joshua76it** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 4:12 pm

like it or not, NCB was , and will remain, one of their latest big hits all over the world.

personally, i never liked it, but may the 'Boys have one more big hit like that!

Radiophonic · #52 Post by **Radiophonic** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 4:17 pm

So was 'The Birdy Song'...

Ray · #53 Post by **Ray** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 5:19 pm

Radiophonic wrote:"You'll never have a bored day" for one thing.

When you're a boy, some days are tough.

Does not serve too well as a proof that Neil is one of the greatest lyricists in the history of pop music.

DogWater · #54 Post by **DogWater** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 5:57 pm

The Montage video - a sorry attempt at livening up some very dull footage. I still can't believe it got past their otherwise immpecable quality control.

And what's that boring cover for "A Life in Pop" all about?

What's everybody's problem with Disco 2? Though hardly a classic, it's still a bit of fun.

stoo · #55 Post by **stoo** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 9:23 pm

Saturday night forever...worst album track to date
the sound of....crap
the I get along video...a poor mans being boring
disco 2.. a let down considering the songs available
boy strange...don't like the vocal
home and dry video( tedious)
New York city boy...worst single to date

ClyCly · #56 Post by **ClyCly** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 10:17 pm

Umm interesting question. For me it would be Disco 2 that I don't like, the Sound of the Atom Splitting, the remix of Liberation by E-Smove and the Home and Dry video.

Cheers,

Cly xxx

Radiophonic · #57 Post by **Radiophonic** » Sat 14 Jul 2007, 11:51 pm

ClyCly wrote:Umm interesting question. For me it would be Disco 2 that I don't like, the Sound of the Atom Splitting, the remix of Liberation by E-Smove and the Home and Dry video.

Yes, Yess, ugh yes and, sadly, yes.

Undertaker · #58 Post by **Undertaker** » Sun 15 Jul 2007, 1:03 am

That West End Girls performance on Life In Pop. Although it is very funny as well.

Dave

Glenny4 · #59 Post by **Glenny4** » Sun 15 Jul 2007, 1:19 am

The thing about the Sound of the Atom Splitting for me.

It's just PSB trying out acid house : He's a villain, him over there with the stocking on his head
Look, there's another, they call themselves 'pinheads' you got to laugh at that

well you have in my world

So i could never hate something i have a good giggle about

unlike shite Disco potential first 2 min

Dipso · #60 Post by **Dipso** » Sun 15 Jul 2007, 2:53 am

The Sound Of Atom Splitting is something to do with a Derek Jarman film, I believe. It worked fantastically as an instrumental on the 1989 tour. I agree that the version with lyrics is somewhat odd, although it is supposed to be, I would imagine. Not that I have listened to it for years!

If I could scrub any of the singles it would be New York City Boy. The song and the video are both horribly cheesy, imho. The Pets sometimes complain that they are marginalised by being labelled as "camp" or "gay". Well, duh!