She's Madonna

Message

Rent · #16 Post by **Rent** » Sun 15 Oct 2006, 8:07 pm

Dear lord, how utterly boring (read crap).

I'll just repeat what I said: can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.

Phillip · #17 Post by **Phillip** » Sun 15 Oct 2006, 10:59 pm

I know another one You can't polish a turd.

Markpro · #18 Post by **Markpro** » Mon 16 Oct 2006, 9:14 am

I love it, i really like Louise as well (not relevant but just thought i'd add my two cents worth).
Was really surprised with we're the pet shop boys as well, it's better than "Our" version

Rent · #19 Post by **Rent** » Mon 16 Oct 2006, 9:29 am

Phillip wrote:I know another one You can't polish a turd.

Well done. Much better!

Grover · #20 Post by **Grover** » Mon 16 Oct 2006, 1:55 pm

StevePSB wrote:Yep, no links to copyrighted files please. Thank you.

StevePSB

Oops... my apologies Steve. I sincerely didn't realize when I copied that link from the other forum. I will pay attention better next time.

dVTB · #21 Post by **dVTB** » Tue 17 Oct 2006, 7:22 pm

Much to my surprise, Dutch Radio 2, the most popular radio station in this country, played She's Madonna this afternoon. The DJ didn't mention PSB producing it, but did tell that it's a new track on Robbie's album.

dannii · #22 Post by **dannii** » Tue 17 Oct 2006, 7:38 pm

is there a PSB demo of ''She's Madonna''
they've probably done it and it might be released on future Fundamental further listening

! · #23 Post by ! » Tue 17 Oct 2006, 8:05 pm

Rent wrote:Dear lord, how utterly boring (read crap).

I'll just repeat what I said: can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.

Phillip wrote:I know another one You can't polish a turd.

Very true.

Darkmoon · #24 Post by **Darkmoon** » Wed 18 Oct 2006, 3:55 pm

Just heard the track
It's great! For me the greatest thing are the verses, (strangely enough it sounds like something I once wrote), I say bring on an entire PSB+Robbie album! It's time they did an all male-album.

psblogan · #25 Post by **psblogan** » Mon 23 Oct 2006, 12:37 pm

I find that it reminds me of a 'Take That' reunion song!
Don't get me wrong, That Take were great 90's pop.
We're The Pet Shop Boys could have sounded a bit more Robbie ish.

Panbaams · #26 Post by **Panbaams** » Wed 29 Nov 2006, 5:16 pm

Bump.

Could some kind soul who bought Rudebox pass on the writing/production details for "She's Madonna" and "We're the Pet Shop Boys"? I downloaded those two songs (legally, I hasten to add) rather than buy the whole album and it'd be nice to put the details on a proper sleeve for them ...

ultraplus · #27 Post by **ultraplus** » Thu 30 Nov 2006, 12:25 am

"She's Madonna" is good. Sounds like the Pet Shop Boys not Robbie.
Which it probably why it is good. His cover of Stephen Duffy's "Kiss
Me" is bad. Bad. Bad.

Robbie Williams.. There is an air of homosexual about him. Hawt!

PSBehaviour · #28 Post by **PSBehaviour** » Thu 30 Nov 2006, 1:22 am

She's boring. (That's closer to the truth IMHO)

EricMontreal22 · #29 Post by **EricMontreal22** » Thu 30 Nov 2006, 12:02 pm

Panbaams wrote:Bump.

Could some kind soul who bought Rudebox pass on the writing/production details for "She's Madonna" and "We're the Pet Shop Boys"? I downloaded those two songs (legally, I hasten to add) rather than buy the whole album and it'd be nice to put the details on a proper sleeve for them ...

Sure! First I never noticed even in the booklet both songs are credited "Robbie Williams with Pet Shop Boys" also that Neil is given backing vocal credit for Pet Shop Boys but I hear him more on Madonna

Anyway for here're the credits with the spacing and punctuation as given in the booklet exactly

SHE'S MADONNA
Robbie Williams
with Pet Shop Boys

Lead Vocals:
Robbie Williams

Programming:
Chris Lowe
Peter Gleadall

Produced by:
Pet Shop Boys
Mixed by:
Tim Weidner

Written by R.Williams/
N. Tennat/C. Lowe
Published by BMG Music
Publishing Ltd/Cage
Music Ltd/Sony ATV
Music Ltd.

WE'RE THE PET SHOP BOYS
Robbie Williams
with Pet Shop Boys

Lead Vocals:
Robbie Williams

Backing Vocals:
Neil Tennant

Original Production by:
Chris Zippel
Pet Shop Boys
Mixed by:
Tim Weidner

Written by My Robot
Friend. Published by Tape
Recorder Music (ASCAP)

EricMontreal22 · #30 Post by **EricMontreal22** » Thu 30 Nov 2006, 12:04 pm

ultraplus wrote:"Robbie Williams.. There is an air of homosexual about him. Hawt!

I'm a minor fan but I don'tfind this "ir" hot because he parades and hints at it every chance he gets in the media so that it seems desperate to just keep gay fans hoping he might be. (Among other stunts liek his weird completely nude video file for his last labum)

But I love half the album and LOVE She's Madonna--killer chords in the verses. His We're the PEt Shop Boys is decent, the production is a tiny improvement on the bside version but it's still an odd choice to cover.

If this song does get a single release will we get a bside of a third Robby/PSB collaboration??

E