Page 9 of 11
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 11:41 am
by Ghost within this house
I'm encouraged by the reviews except that if Building a wall is as bad / misjudged as everyone is saying that's a real shame... it sounds a bit 'novelty' and if its crap and there's a stinker bang in the middle of the album..... not good
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 1:15 pm
by Northernerrj
I like to read all the reviews that have been posted on the net, but I'll wait to listen on my own and see whether I'll like it or not.
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 2:50 pm
by Oznerol
Northernerrj wrote:I like to read all the reviews that have been posted on the net, but I'll wait to listen on my own and see whether I'll like it or not.
Just like the 99.9% of the fans here
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 3:25 pm
by drunk14
Thank you for review, so after these 3 texts, my cogitation:
1 group: Great songs
- Pandemonium
- The Way The Used To Be
- King Of Rome
- Love Etc
2 group: Good songs
- More Than A Dream
- Did You See Me Coming?
- Beautiful People
3 group: Average, but in PSB standards
- Vulnerable
- All Over The World
4 group: Hmmm
- Building A Wall
- Legacy
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 3:43 pm
by pendolino
What I don’t understand is why so many people (well,at least, the lucky ones that heard the album) complain about the lyrics (they say the lyrics are weak, that there isn’t a strong quote, etc). The boys said they wanted to make a pop (and commercial) album. I think that’s why the lyrics aren’t strong or even cliché. Profound lyrics could make the album “too serious” for potencial listeners.
Still two months ahead..... I can't wait !!!!!!
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 3:45 pm
by Nickname
drunk14 wrote:Thank you for review, so after these 3 texts, my cogitation:
1 group: Great songs
- Pandemonium
- The Way The Used To Be
- King Of Rome
- Love Etc
2 group: Good songs
- More Than A Dream
- Did You See Me Coming?
- Beautiful People
3 group: Average, but in PSB standards
- Vulnerable
- All Over The World
4 group: Hmmm
- Building A Wall
- Legacy
PJ and one of the other reviewers think "All over the World" has to be the second single. So it's not average. It's in the group of the great songs (according to most of the reviewers). "This is a song about boys and girls" (it's like they had included "girls" because they planned this song to be commercial). "It's superficial and true / easy and predictable / exciting and new / to say ’I want you'" (ironic or not it sounds like Pet Shop Boys was trying to sound cool with a beautiful song for teenagers, according to Eldritch "they should leave it for the likes of Take That").
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 4:03 pm
by drunk14
Yes, i know, but ''our forum'' reviewers are not satisfied to hear this song
After all, I'm also interesting this one. I would like to say it's my favourite song when i will get and hear Yes
Its descriptions sound so good!...only fragment about Take That it's dauting
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 4:55 pm
by Very
Is Pandemonium better than Paninaro '95?
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 5:06 pm
by drunk14
Or maybe better than Silver Age
What else?
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 8:21 pm
by psb-freak
Well, a bit over a week for the radio play of Love etc according to official site. Can´t wait.
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 8:43 pm
by Blogo
I really excited I hope it becomes a real hit....... 3 weeks in top 20
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Wed 28 Jan 2009, 9:01 pm
by MD
Deschanel wrote:One very great thing about PSB is that even if the album tracks might disappoint, there is always some fantastic remix that blows me away and makes me change my mind. That will be the one I have on repeat, enjoying for days and weeks. Then I come around to really loving the album track it came from.
This has happened again and again. Certainly with Fundamental, a time-release CD if ever there was.
I may have found most of it gloomy and a downer at first, but it certainly grew on me, and I see how hasty I was judging it. Maybe this is the mark of very good artists..it's not instantly accessible, then disposable.
And then there are the b-sides and marvellous freaksongs that appear from left field, like Fugitive, while the album is still a going concern. So..never dull. Is it March yet?
I am getting a bit excited for this album. It sounds like it is more "Upbeat" than Fundy, but that album could have done with a few less down-tempo tracks in my view. I'm looking for Yes to be slightly better than Fundy, If they pull that off I will be thrilled
If its good enough to get into the Please, Very or Behaviour territory I will require a change of shorts
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Thu 29 Jan 2009, 1:02 pm
by Axonthenet
I've red here and elsewhere that some reviewers are disappointed by the lyrics of the songs of "Yes". They say they are too obvious for the PSB standars... but hasn't Neil said that "Yes" is their most commercial record in 15 years? I haven't listened to "Yes", but in my opinion is clear that the lyrics have been written to be lighter by purpose...
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Thu 29 Jan 2009, 10:07 pm
by glennjridge
I always get hit by the music first,lyrics second anyways.
consider some of the lyrics to "the loving kind", "sometimes I watch you when your sleeping" I mean he didnt reinvent the wheel, and yet they sound great on the track and serve its purpose.
if they are targeting a younger crowd more into pop I can totally see why the lyrics would be more light and bubblegum which is fine with me.
Re: Yes, Pet Shop Boys. (the first forum review) UPDATED
Posted: Thu 29 Jan 2009, 11:24 pm
by Lleonard Pler
What worries me about the lyrics is all that "boys and girls", "a boy needs a girl", "wife" stuff. Like they can lie anyone now. I prefer their ambiguous, yet sincere lyrics.