Page 8 of 9
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 3:19 pm
by Dipso
E-Mail Vampire wrote:Not in my area no as I only have Woolies and Music Zone. The nearest HMV is Luton or Milton Keynes. My only hope now is Amazon which are now saying 4-6 weeks for posting
The HMV website has all three formats in stock. Actually, they despatched my 7" vinyl single yesterday so they have all four in stock!
HMV
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 3:26 pm
by Tomas
Dipso wrote:The HMV website has all three formats in stock. Actually, they despatched my 7" vinyl single yesterday so they have all four in stock!
They don't ship to EU / Czech Republic!

Should I move to Mali?
Anyway, it's a question what they'd ask for shipping. Amazon.co.uk ask many more for shipping to CZ than to Greece for example. Crazy.
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 3:53 pm
by profile790
Drico One wrote:stats-freak wrote:The formats of Minimal are OK... - The 2-track cd-single isn't very attractive, but die-hard fans buy it anyway, and so might some Elton John fans. The remix cd-single is OK too, the DVD single is a fan only thing, but many fans will buy it.
I didn't. Am I a diehard fan? I would consider myself to be. However, I am not myopic. I had a look at the releases and decided that they weren't worth purchasing. The 2-track CD is only of interest to me if it contains a must-have b-side (in other words, something new rather than a cut down version of a hand-me-down from a previous project). I don't collect for the sake of it.
I'm simply going to get the German maxi-single instead. That way I get the real b-side (or bonus track in corporate speak) on CD. Hiding it away on DVD and making it difficult to listen to on the move is just too dismissive of the fan for my comfort.
No, you're not a die-hard fan. You slag off PSB too much. Anyway, the few 'fans' who don't buy cd1 are probably compensated by Elton John fans who *do* buy this release. I also would have preferred Blue On Blue on cd1, but I don't really see how putting In Private there damages sales. Non PSB-fans who only like Minimal, will only buy cd2 anyway. So would I, if I weren't a PSB fan.
As far as I know, there's NO German cd-single this time that has the same content as the DVD (without the video).
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 3:55 pm
by No Muscle Mary
In Drico's defence, I'm a die-hard fan and I slag them off constantly.
You don't have to think someone is perfect or all the work they produce is perfect to still be a devoted fan. People do have minds of their own.
He's a fan, he's not brainwashed.
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 4:05 pm
by E-Mail Vampire
Dipso wrote:E-Mail Vampire wrote:Not in my area no as I only have Woolies and Music Zone. The nearest HMV is Luton or Milton Keynes. My only hope now is Amazon which are now saying 4-6 weeks for posting
The HMV website has all three formats in stock. Actually, they despatched my 7" vinyl single yesterday so they have all four in stock!
HMV
Unfortunatey theydo not take my card

and I have a previous bad experience with a DVD single.
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 4:56 pm
by gomorrah
No Muscle Mary wrote:In Drico's defence, I'm a die-hard fan and I slag them off constantly.
You don't have to think someone is perfect or all the work they produce is perfect to still be a devoted fan. People do have minds of their own.
He's a fan, he's not brainwashed.
exactly. I love PSB but I refuse to be sheep and not speak my mind.
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 5:08 pm
by patrick
stats-freak wrote:No, you're not a die-hard fan.
Oh, please.
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 5:11 pm
by joncool5
stats-freak wrote:No, you're not a die-hard fan.
I've got more records than you, nah, nah, nah, nah, nah....
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 8:53 pm
by Janet Street-Porter
If you really want the single you'll walk up the high street to HMV or Virgin to buy it. I've never bought a single in Woolworth's - sweets and dolls for my niece but never any music. I imagine X-Factor acts do well in there.
I *love* Minimal but don't think it's actually going to appeal to the man in the street. As the Channel 4 review pointed out, it's probably their most dance orientated single ever and electro Kraftwerkian odes to minimalism tend not to top the charts.
fanatical FANTASIES
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 11:01 pm
by reality_check
retrofuturist wrote:
My point was that if someone wants to buy it they probably will... even if it means trying a couple of different stores over a period of a couple of weeks. Spreading out the sales might give Minimal (and consequently Fundamental) more prolonged media exposure.
This means the casual buyers (who you rightfully mention, yet alas contribute little to PSB sales) have more chance of hearing the song in the first place since it's in the charts for longer. This should offset the obvious negative impact you've outlined above to some extent.
In the past, some 2-part CD singles were
intentionally released a week apart in order to achieve this very outcome. Come to think of it, isn't the Minimal 7" released next week???
As others have said in various threads, the role of the single nowadays is almost purely about promoting the album... it's not about chart positions. Hence, my view that it might not be a complete disaster if Woolworths haven't properly stocked it yet.... although tying it back to the point of this thread, it will impact the possibility of a Top 10 finish.
Retro.

The point is when you make these soothing 'theories' you forget about all the facts that contradict your rosy specticled predictions.Woolies have not been stocking PSB singles for ages - all their more recents singles still plummet out of the chart in the second week AND make negligable differance to promoting/selling more copies of the album.
That you are completely BARKIN' in your beliefs is concluded by the following FACT!!!
Tomas wrote:When you <retrofuturist> talk about this - any ideas anyone what's Fundamental mid-week position this week?
DazzerUKUK wrote:
It's 187.
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 11:19 pm
by Technotrancemix
If you "claim" you are a fan but criticise the PSB 50%+ of the time, you aren't really a fan.
That's what many so-called-fans do on the forum...
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 11:25 pm
by Pani
Technotrancemix wrote:If you "claim" you are a fan but criticise the PSB 50%+ of ...
100 %.
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 11:27 pm
by Pani
joncool5 wrote:stats-freak wrote:No, you're not a die-hard fan.
I've got more records than you, nah, nah, nah, nah, nah....
Being collectors, yes ... ?
Posted: Fri 28 Jul 2006, 11:28 pm
by Drico One
Technotrancemix wrote:If you "claim" you are a fan but criticise the PSB 50%+ of the time, you aren't really a fan.
That's what many so-called-fans do on the forum...
Who are these imposters? They really must be exposed to full public opprobrium.
Drico.
Posted: Sat 29 Jul 2006, 12:04 am
by Technotrancemix
Drico One wrote:Who are these imposters? They really must be exposed to full public opprobrium.
Drico.
The majority of fans Drico
At least when you, the "fan from the western foreign depths of Europe" criticises, you do it for good reason
As a fan myself, I criticise PSB somewhere between 5-10% of the time. And you could claim I am more a fan-based collector of PSB releases but I'm not sure what you'd all think if I told you I've yet to purchase Minimal single yet..
