Page 3 of 3
Re: It's a river, not a canal...
Posted: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 4:24 pm
by OakeyDokey
Tom Angel wrote: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 10:30 am
That it's a river, not a canal is particularly galling to me as I just bought a narrow boat on the basis of hearing the lyric as a good omen!
Blimey, more money than sense

Re: It's a river, not a canal...
Posted: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 4:49 pm
by Patrick Bateman
Adam Tremadoc wrote: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 3:34 pmComing from one of the most omnipresent posters on a fan forum for said act, one could almost call this irony.
Not sure it's irony, I'd just rather listen to it for the first time with fewer preconceptions. Won't read anything by people who attend the playback either.
Re: It's a river, not a canal...
Posted: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 5:09 pm
by Sandy Shaw
Tom Angel wrote: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 10:30 am
That it's a river, not a canal is particularly galling to me as I just bought a narrow boat on the basis of hearing the lyric as a good omen!
In fact not just ''a river', but the Thames!
Re: It's a river, not a canal...
Posted: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 5:39 pm
by TallThinMan
Drico One wrote: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 10:48 am
They've changed how they write in recent years, haven't they? Neil writes the words and sends them to Chris, who sets them to music. Wrack my memory here, but isn't that a departure from how they used to write? I thought I read a while back that it was once the other way around, but maybe I'm hallucinating...
Drico.
I think that historically the writing process has been Chris producing an entire piece of music he's written for Neil to set words to, or them being in a room together creating something from scratch, or Chris finishing some music that Neil has started. I believe that Neil "doing a Bernie" and sending the words through to Chris to write music for came out of the enforced separation of lockdown. Having just written that, wasn't that also going on during the 'Yes' writing sessions when Chris was packed upstairs at Xenomania towers to work on the music and Neil was in a separate room "lyricing"?
Re: It's a river, not a canal...
Posted: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 6:10 pm
by petshopgrrl
Tom Angel wrote: Thu 11 Apr 2024, 10:30 am
That it's a river, not a canal is particularly galling to me as I just bought a narrow boat on the basis of hearing the lyric as a good omen!

And I'm canceling my flight to Paris!
God, we're terrible, aren't we. I bet the former editor is always thrilled to be pulled up by Pedantic Petheads. We're all only human, after all.