Pet Shop Boys Community

stats-freak wrote:I still have to figure out some things before I can open this massive topic.

Let's talk about the first group of 'dubious' tracks: Friendly Fire, No Time For Tears, In Private and Girls & Boys (live). - I suggest either to include ALL these tracks, or NONE.

Difficult is Positive Role Model... I'm still in doubt about that one. It was *only* a B-side on a German cd-single. In the Rank The Singles topic, I did *not* include To Step Aside, which was only an AA-side in the USA. I also did *not* include Break 4 Love, a US-single only. Which suggests I should treat it as a B-side now.

Another thing to figure out, is how to deal with the fact that some people don't know all songs. Let's say - for instance - that somebody doesn't know Blue On Blue and can't vote for it. How should I calculate the votes in the end? I have several options.

For people who fill in the full list, the #1 song will get 63 points, the #2 song gets 62... and so on. But what if somebody doesn't know five B-sides? Should I give the #1 song 63 points and so on? Should I give it 58 points? (Since the person fills in only 58 songs). How should I calculate the total result? Should I take the average, or total vote? It's all very confusing and way more difficult than the Rank The Singles topic, since everybody knows those songs...

Suggestions are welcome. Depending on how fast I get them, I can open the topic either tonight or on Sunday (since I'm busy on Saturday).

retrofuturist wrote:

adiba wrote:

retrofuturist wrote:To confuse things even more... yes, No Time For Tears is an album track. But it's not a Pet Shop Boys album track. It is however, a Pet Shop Boys b-side!

I don't know which copy of the Battleship Potemkin soundtrack you own, but on mine it reads "performed by PET SHOP BOYS and Dresdner Sinfoniker"

Aaah... but it's a classical CD, isn't it?

If the Bangladeshi Symphonic Orchestra record an "Essential Works of Mozart" CD full of songs, you'd find it under M for Mozart, not B for Bangladeshi.

Likewise, Battleship Potemkin is the works of Tennant/Lowe, performed by Pet Shop Boys and Dresdner Sinfoniker.

Retro.

stew wrote:Girls and boys among other live tracks you cant really include eitrher as they were just live performances, if you include girls and boys then you have to include all live tracks which were bsides i.e Love comes quickly...that would be confusing...

i would keep break 4 love as most people didnt hear it until was released as bside and only own it as bside.

stew wrote:SO IT IS THEN ...
would you count love comes quickly and a red letter day as Bsides though ? ? ? ?

i thought they were just counted as like extras when they put live stuff on ????

im confused!

retrofuturist wrote:Maybe that's why it's under the name Tennant/Lowe. When that's all said and done, it is what it is... Tennant/Lowe. Just as the spine says...

Can we debate Absolutely Fabulous too?

One of the crowd wrote:

stew wrote:SO IT IS THEN ...
would you count love comes quickly and a red letter day as Bsides though ? ? ? ?

i thought they were just counted as like extras when they put live stuff on ????

im confused!

No, but considering that the recording of Girls and Boys (Live) is the only version we have AND it was a Bside, I think we should include it, whereas whoever mentioned Fugitive, sorry but this is an album track, albeit on a bonus CD (thats like inlcuding Generic Jingle)

One of the crowd wrote:No, what I meant was, whereas we have live versions of Love comes quickly, RLD, Always on my mind, BB etc - these have already been singles and are therefore not bside material, whereas Girls And Boys IS A bside.

Now if Girls and Boys had already been released as a studio version on say Actually, then we should not be including it for the same reason Violence (Hacienda Version), Can you forgive her?? (Swing Mix), I want to wake up (JMarr mix) etc isnt included on the list.

stats-freak wrote:

One of the crowd wrote:No, what I meant was, whereas we have live versions of Love comes quickly, RLD, Always on my mind, BB etc - these have already been singles and are therefore not bside material, whereas Girls And Boys IS A bside.

Now if Girls and Boys had already been released as a studio version on say Actually, then we should not be including it for the same reason Violence (Hacienda Version), Can you forgive her?? (Swing Mix), I want to wake up (JMarr mix) etc isnt included on the list.

I agree with this. I don't intend to include different versions of earlier songs. So no Love comes quickly and ALRD live, no Always on my mind and BB live, no Violence, no Can you forgive her?, no I Want To Wake Up.... - But what to do with In Private? *raaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah*