Erasure Dont Deserve a Brit Outstanding Achievement

[pulse]

Oh you've caught me! lol

Dear Lord, the grandstanding never ends...

[Loins Of London]

if Lifetime Achievement Awards can be given to Wham! in 86 (George Michael now? Certainly. Circa Older? Definitely. Circa Listen Without Prejudice? OK. But not Wham! in 86), Status Quo (whom I've nothing against, but surely there is little you accuse any long running act of that you can't accuse them of, even in 91), possibly even The Police in 85 (great though they were) and definitely The Spice Girls in 2000(!).

Yeah I have some sympathies with what you're saying, but at the 1986 show, and even though they'd only released two albums, Wham! were specifically given the award because they were the first band to play China (and they'd just announced they were splitting, which helped!). They shared it with Elton, who had played Russia, although that part always seemed something of an afterthought, seeing as it was eight years after the event.

The Police obviously got it the year before as they'd just split up. In fact I can't remember if all three actually turned up to received the prestigious doorstops or not.

As for the unsavoury Spices, well, as Morrissey once said, it's "indiscussable."

I would probably place Erasure about on a par with Eurythmics.

Incidentally, regarding the commercial success of post-Brit award albums, Eurythmic's Peace got to Number 4 and spent twenty weaks on the UK chart. Quite feasible for the Boys I would think, yet it would still be the best chart performance for an album since Very (I think).

I'd certainly place Eurythmics a lot higher than Erasure in terms of impact, sales, success in the US, diversity, vocals etc, but, yeah, part of the reason they got the Brit when they did was that they'd just reformed and no one knew how temporary it was, least of all them. They'd originally planned on just two new recordings for an updated Greatest Hits to tie-in with the award, but, instead, the Peace album followed The Brits about eight months later.

[skyhigh]

Coming from a person who thinks Vince and Andy planned to foil PSB's special day by releasing a couple of albums around that time, which, in case you don't know, takes months of planning *by the label* as well. Priceless.

No amount of education makes up for a lack of common sense. To me it seems you like to feign some sort of bravado on this board by belittling others and grandstanding. Really, really cheesy.

An Erasure fan is calling me cheesy? Clearly you don't understand irony either.

Oh, and the albums in question were planned for release this month, but, mysteriously, now delayed to show up either side of Brits week.

You do the maths. On second thoughts, don't bother, I wouldn't want you to embarrass yourself any more than you already have.

Are you 14? What's with the never-ending grandstanding for the crowd? Apparently, for someone who hates Erasure so much, you certainly know a lot about their scrapped release plans. People were assuming that the release was planned for November - but Vince and Andy forced them at gunpoint to change this release date to spite their enemies lol. I think the only one embarrassing himself is you, my friend. And can you not make a point without hurdling an insult just once, or not trying to get the crowd to cheer like a 14 year old girl on a popularity rampage?

in all of loins posts i havent actually noticed anything to suggest he hates erasure. it's all been very factual and reasoned. would say its highly likely he doesnt rate them in the same league as psb but no mention of hate.

[JSDOUVRES]

Factual and reasoned? Hardly that is it? Apparently because Erasure have not been that succesful since the mid 90's (exactly like the PSB!) they don't deserve an award? Are groups only judged after that period? Obviously not! And the Madonna remix? Who gives a f**k! hardly deserving of a brit! Was the Robbie collaboration really a hit? No. Not even worth mentioning the others to be honest, but it doesn't matter does it? It's all about the music, oh wait, unless your Erasure!

[glennjridge]

makes a point. this is really a bizzare argument anyways. PSB/erasure, its really a case of apples and oranges in the big picture sense.

[Loins Of London]

Apparently because Erasure have not been that succesful since the mid 90's (exactly like the PSB!) they don't deserve an award?

In case it's slipped your mind, once again, the last five Erasure albums reached 45, 17, 27, 102 and 29, whereas all of the PSBs reached the top ten.

Anything additional that PSB can do to keep their profile at a reasonable level helps, that includes a co-write on the current No.1 album from the biggest girl group in Britain, and, yep, a mere remix for the biggest female singer in the world. Still, at least Cyndi Lauper wanted to work with Erasure so they weren't completely left out on the femme fatale front.

Hmmm, sounds like it may be time for a poll.

[glennjridge]

the trouble with that thinking is,if you decide who is worthy on the sales of their last few CD's ,rather than look at the longevity of their creating music stretching over a long history then I think you'll find possibly even past winners didnt deserve the award at the point they recieved the award.

the pharasing is lifetime achievement award.
like I said its like comparing apples and oranges. they are both fruits.

[JSDOUVRES]

Apparently because Erasure have not been that succesful since the mid 90's (exactly like the PSB!) they don't deserve an award?

In case it's slipped your mind, once again, the last five Erasure albums reached 45, 17, 27, 102 and 29, whereas all of the PSBs reached the top ten.

Anything additional that PSB can do to keep their profile at a reasonable level helps, that includes a co-write on the current No.1 album from the biggest girl group in Britain, and, yep, a mere remix for the biggest female singer in the world. Still, at least Cyndi Lauper wanted to work with Erasure so they weren't completely left out on the femme fatale front.

Hmmm, sounds like it may be time for a poll.

Great stats again and nice try but you've included Union Street which is actually not a studio album but an acoustic album which reached 102, Also you forget the Erasure album released in 1995 that reached 14 and Cowboy released in 1997 that reached 10. Not too bad wouldn't you say?
Oh and Disco 3 reached a fabulous 36 and concrete 61. SO much better than Erasure!!!!!
Funny that you include Union street but leave out Disco 3 and Concrete! Nice Try!!!
Oh and CTH got to 107 and Battleship Potemkin 97 so you might want to make sure you eliminate the PSB side projects from your examples of how much better they chart.
Wouldn't you look at the last two greatest hits chart placings as well? Erasure 15 and the PSB 30. Hardly top 10 there. In fact Erasure were 15 places higher. But does not matter because they didn't remix Madonna!!!!!!
Any new rules and regulations you want to make up to back up your 'PSB are the Best' Campaign?

[Loins Of London]

the pharasing is lifetime achievement award.

It's actually titled The Outstanding Contribution award. If I may quote myself from earlier in this very thread:

23 acts can claim more No.1 albums than Erasure, and that includes The Shadows, Led Zeppelin, REM, ABBA, Elvis, Madonna, Robbie, Dylan, Genesis, Springsteen and the Rolling Stones.

None of them have received said award, but I'd hazard a guess that some of those acts will be in line for the top honour waaaaay before Erasure.

I think the PSB seem more relevant only because we are such big fans of them. some of the same points against erasure would apply to the PSB today.

besides, atleast at the award shows here in america, the lifetime achievement award (which would be the equivelent)isnt givin to acts at the top of their game, its always seems to be some sad recognition that gets doled out when the band is faultering and about to slide away so they sort of throw them a sort of lifeline before they totally go away and say, hey, before you go, you were awesome.....once.

The Brits isn't the same concept as the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame though.

Look at the list of previous winners since the show was televised:

2008 Paul McCartney
2007 Oasis
2006 Paul Weller
2005 Bob Geldof
2004 Duran Duran
2003 Tom Jones
2002 Sting
2001 U2
2000 Spice Girls
1999 Eurythmics
1998 Fleetwood Mac
1997 Bee Gees
1996 David Bowie
1995 Elton John
1994 Van Morrison
1993 Rod Stewart
1992 Freddie Mercury
1991 Status Quo
1990 Queen
1989 Cliff Richard
1988 The Who
1987 Eric Clapton
1986 Elton John & Wham!
1985 The Police
1984 George Martin
1983 The Beatles
1982 John Lennon

Posthumous awards to Mercury and Lennon aside, every musical act bar the Beatles and Geldof (who was basically awarded for his charitable projects the year after Live Eight) was still a going concern at the time, either capable of having top ten albums and/or filling out large arenas and/or stadiums. The same does not apply to Erasure, who have had one solitary top ten album since their last chart-topper almost 15 years ago, Cowboy a brief No.10 in 1997.

[glennjridge]

whatever same idea. I mean looking at that list there are some deserving artists obviously, but come on, erasure woulnt be out of place with some of that lot.

if you consider even one a weak link in that list,(and quite frankly I see at least 4) then throw erasure on.

I mean, tom jones.....come on.

[Undertaker]

[quote="Loins Of London'']Do you really think that anyone is really going to take you seriously when a quick glance at your profile stats on this, a Pet Shop Boys forum shows that:

Most active topic: Erasure's new single
[ 25 Posts / 14.29% of user’s posts ]

Now that's what I call contrary.[/quote]

Obviously you are unaware of Pulse's (a.k.a Stephano) bitterness. If you do a search, you will see no end of onslaughts aimed at PSB. At the end of the day though, it just comes down to bittterness again. PSB are getting the biggest award in British music and he cannot accept it. Still, these cameo performances he makes on here all makes for good entertainment. You have to feel slightly sorry for him though. He made a video free of charge for Erasure but they chose to release a video of Andy just sat on a toilet

His posts are so obvious. You just know he will try and put PSB down at every opportunity but then add a little compliment at the end, hoping that people cannot see straight through his envious rants.

PSB - Winners of the Outstanding Contribution to Music Award 2009

[Undertaker]

Well, I hate to rain on this particular parade, but I think it would be a stretch for anyone to say PSB are making "groundbreaking music". If one was to listen to the latest album, I would assume 99%+ would not label it anywhere near groundbreaking. It doesn't have to be groundbreaking to be good.

This isn't the most desperate post you have made... but it's in the top 3.

Have you not heard Fugitive? Even the fantastic Integral. Fugitive blows out the water anything any other synth band has ever produced.

No wonder there are rumours about that Mickey Mouse wears a Stephano wrist watch.

[Loins Of London]

You have to feel slightly sorry for him though. He made a video free of charge for Erasure but they chose to release a video of Andy just sat on a toilet

Forgive me if I don't look out for that one. I'm Bell-End-phobic.

[pulse]

Well, I hate to rain on this particular parade, but I think it would be a stretch for anyone to say PSB are making "groundbreaking music". If one was to listen to the latest album, I would assume 99%+ would not label it anywhere near groundbreaking. It doesn't have to be groundbreaking to be good.

This isn't the most desperate post you have made... but it's in the top 3.

Have you not heard Fugitive? Even the fantastic Integral. Fugitive blows out the water anything any other synth band has ever produced.

No wonder there are rumours about that Mickey Mouse wears a Stephano wrist watch.

Once again, resorting to personal attacks when your limited intelligence can only take you so far. You're obviously great at "toilet humour" aren't you? Go ahead, make'm proud with your wit lol.

How is Fugitive groundbreaking? AND "Integral"? Groundbreaking?? Give your head a shake, man. They may be good songs but hardly groundbreaking. This is one of the first times that I actually think you've completely lost the plot. You're usually rather snipey, bitter, misinformed, repetitious, personal, low, and bellicose, but this time... I just realised that you are actually serious. You actually believe that. Wow. Well, all the power to you. I guess we are all subject to our own tastes and opinions.

And I would love it if Mickey wore a wristwatch with me on it - at least that would be just a little more groundbreaking than PSB's music lol. (The preceding was not an insult - good music, yes. Groundbreaking, not so much).

[Loins Of London]

quote="skyhigh"]

in all of loins posts i havent actually noticed anything to suggest he hates erasure. it's all been very factual and reasoned. would say its highly likely he doesnt rate them in the same league as psb but no mention of hate.[/quote]

Well, for starters, I wouldn't be stupid enough to post on an Erasure forum...