Pet Shop Boys Community

Where can I get an mp3 of this?

(its not a commercial release, so can't hurt to have an mp3 of the demo!)

Don't be so naughty.

I have it.

It´s great song. Although don´t have it on computer... On cd.

I hope they do a proper recording of it. The version I have (and I'm sure the one everybody else has) is a live recording from the John Peel show.

hope you got it! If not - mail me!

It may be non commercial, but it is still copyrighted material. Please don't ask for copyrighted material in public, it is against the rules of the forum.

Thank you.


StevePSB

Don't have it. Is it not available anywhere?

"Heeeeeeee's got a powerful friend..."

! wrote:I hope they do a proper recording of it. The version I have (and I'm sure the one everybody else has) is a live recording from the John Peel show.

That was a John Peel session, recorded at Maida Vale Studios, not a live recording.

Andy

StevePSB wrote:It may be non commercial, but it is still copyrighted material. Please don't ask for copyrighted material in public, it is against the rules of the forum.

Nothing against the rules, only a related technical question - if I record a song from the radio, am I breaking copyrights by the very act of recording it?

no, but you breaking the rules, if you make the record available over the internet shortly after!

Here's one oddity that I've got burned onto a cd!

Everybody got a version with a "fade-in" intro?

TheGardner wrote:no, but you breaking the rules, if you make the record available over the internet shortly after!

Hmm, if it is so, then I dare to ask one "devil's advocate" question.

I do understand that for example copying original CDs is a different / illegal case, when only the original CD gave profit - when first sold - to the artist, not the copies.

But what is the difference between:
a) 10 people make their own recording of a song from the radio = 10 people have the radio recording
b) 1 person makes a recording of a song from the radio and makes a copy for other 9 people = 10 people have the radio recording
Why should anyone be blamed / warned etc. for putting up something that everyone could have recorded legally (?) and for free from the radio? (Well of course not everyone literally is receiving BBC Radio, but that's only a side fact IMO.)

Please understand I don't want any bad argue, I'm just trying to put things in a different perspective and see why it actually is morally good or bad, when the result may be the same. But then again, it may still be illegal to even record from a radio, and my speculations are of no avail.