add me to the list of fans of Numb, the PSB versions.
i was as shocked as anyone here when i read they were recording a diane warren song, but was quiet surprised at how quickly it grew on me.
i think the only reason the song works is because PSB did it and its such an unexpected type of trackfrom them. i think the live version is blows the the album version away. i suspect it will be a future single, maybe US only? it could get them back on the radio over here. maybe they held back the track from airing sunday night becuase it will be a future live single?
i wish BBC had aired the entire show. im curious to hear the intros for the unaired songs.
i hope we get the complete show on cd and dvd by the end of the year if not sooner.
NUMB Will Kill Radio 1 RePlaylisting Yes ?
-
dgraysn
- Posts: 325
- Joined: Thu 30 Oct 2003, 7:54 pm
-
skyhigh
- Posts: 3000
- Joined: Thu 29 Jul 2004, 10:48 pm
- Contact:
Numb would destroy fundamentals image if it were released. its guff and doesnt fit well on fundamental, it should be replaced with girls dont cry which is amazing!! see someones usin my avatar too, weird someone with such good taste likes numb so much! 
That's it, it's all over. We're out of here. What a Legacy! (c) Chris Lowe 2009
-
!
- Posts: 2327
- Joined: Mon 23 Jan 2006, 7:13 pm
It fits perfectly.paninaro28 wrote:doesnt fit well on fundamental
Girls Don't Cry is a cheap You Only Tell Me You Love Me When You're Drunk knock-off. It's good but no way amazing. Also, that wouldn't fit well on Fundamental.paninaro28 wrote:it should be replaced with girls dont cry which is amazing!!
Chris and Neil liked it enough topaninaro28 wrote:someone with such good taste likes numb so much!
A) record it
B) consider it for their HITS/Singles album
&
C) put it on their brand new studio album
-
Henrik Powers
- Posts: 568
- Joined: Tue 26 Jul 2005, 8:36 pm
-
Syncratic
- Posts: 1452
- Joined: Sun 01 Aug 2004, 1:33 am
Re: NUMB Will Kill Radio 1 RePlaylisting Yes ?
It doesn't matter because it WON'T happen, and hasn't for many years. Some 12 year old dullard listeners will not give a toss. And for killing off, there's nothing really to kill off. They haven't been playlisted for a long time.dibdav wrote:What do you think about Numb 'killing-off' the Boys being playlisted again on Radio 1 ?
Not that it matters.
But what do you think, MINIMAL gets them back on, only for NUMB to send them flying back off the playlist again.
In a way, a 'very' PSB thing to do, 'self-destructive.'
As far as I'm aware MINIMAL is not on the playlist for radio 1. And I can't see Numb being released. The Diane Warren connection is about as significant as Eminem was to TNIFIL.
-
Propertius
- Posts: 290
- Joined: Mon 29 Dec 2003, 5:45 am
Couldn't "Numb" go some distance with the Radio 2 crowd? It could even do some good in the U.S. Not that it would be a top 40 hit or anything, but iot might actually get played, which is more than can be said for just about anything else PSB have released in the last 15 years. (Although there have been surprising reports of "Home and Dry" getting played.)
I'm really warming up to "Luna Park" now -- I wouldn't be at all unhappy if it were released. Or "Sodom," though I don't think that'll happen. But "Numb" would be a stronger single than either of them.
I'm really warming up to "Luna Park" now -- I wouldn't be at all unhappy if it were released. Or "Sodom," though I don't think that'll happen. But "Numb" would be a stronger single than either of them.
-
Burj
-
Shelton
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sun 11 Jun 2006, 11:59 am
-
Nickname
- Posts: 7892
- Joined: Thu 30 Oct 2003, 2:52 pm
What do you prefer?, another electronic song?, what's the problem of giving a different sound?.
I love Integral and I love The Sodom And Gomorrah Show, really good songs to be singles (better than I'm with stupid and Minimal, for me) but DW knows how to call the attention of general public, and PSB need that. Numb is a really beatiful song and it's not another typical electronic PSB's song, if you want to call their attention give them something different.
I love Integral and I love The Sodom And Gomorrah Show, really good songs to be singles (better than I'm with stupid and Minimal, for me) but DW knows how to call the attention of general public, and PSB need that. Numb is a really beatiful song and it's not another typical electronic PSB's song, if you want to call their attention give them something different.
-
glennjridge
- Posts: 8205
- Joined: Sat 01 Nov 2003, 9:28 pm
it is the most obvious single sounding song on fund even if people here dont like it.gareth wrote:EVERYONE I have spoken to in radio thinks that Numb is the most radio friendly track on the album!
Not that keen myself - but it is growing on me!
some say the PSB should start listening to our opinions when deciding what a new single is, I say they should stop.
cause this pandering to our tastes hasnt been working.
-
E-Mail Vampire
- Posts: 1576
- Joined: Fri 31 Oct 2003, 7:17 am
Exactly I hate Go West and wish it had not been a single but I appreciate that it did something for them in the 90's and was their biggest hit in the 90's. So for that I am glad it was a single.Shelton wrote:As I said in a previous post - Chris Lowe wanted to get Warren to write up a song which he thought would be made into a single - so it looks like we have single material here with Numb - hey just cause you dont like the song dont mean it should not be a single.
cheers
Shelton.
btw I love Numb
-
Burj