Anyone else prefer the new In Private to the Dusty one?

Message

! · #16 Post by ! » Sat 08 Jul 2006, 12:39 am

I think Elton John is the best thing about it!

And no, I'm not an Elton John "fan", I don't have any of his records and I only know that Are Your Ready For Love song from t'other year and his cover of Pinball Wizard.

Jareth · #17 Post by **Jareth** » Sat 08 Jul 2006, 12:50 pm

Elton John is a much stronger vocalist than Dusty Springfield. Most of his material is dreadful however.

It's strange that people hate the backing music so much, yet the incredibly dated Ressurectionist seems to popular here.

Tanja · #18 Post by **Tanja** » Sat 08 Jul 2006, 4:22 pm

I love the Elton John/PSB version of "In Private" and it puzzles me why so many of you hate it. Elton is indeed a strong vocalist and sings perfectly and believably. I just think many of you are nostalgic. Often the first version seems better. I however, heard Dusty's version of "In Private" after I heard Elton's. Besides, I love Elton John. It's an honor for PSB to have Elton on their records.

Twoism · #19 Post by **Twoism** » Sat 08 Jul 2006, 6:17 pm

I prefer the Dusty Springfield's version, thankyou

the last call · #20 Post by **the last call** » Sat 08 Jul 2006, 6:43 pm

Tanja wrote: It's an honor for PSB to have Elton on their records.

What kind of honor is that, if even Blue and Eminem have him.

fasto · #21 Post by **fasto** » Sat 08 Jul 2006, 6:47 pm

I agree that the backing on the new version is rather cheesy, however I prefer it to the old version because that was just too 70s disco / funky for my taste.
I think they tried to do what they did with Go West... take a funky disco tune and turn it into something you can listen to...

Ronald42 · #22 Post by **Ronald42** » Sat 08 Jul 2006, 6:55 pm

the last call wrote:
Tanja wrote: It's an honor for PSB to have Elton on their records.
What kind of honor is that, if even Blue and Eminem have him.

Hmm I read " It's a horror for PSB to have Elton on their records" and I 100% agreed.

The version sung by 2 man making it a gay item works very well I think. I prefer Dusty's version any time but there are some aspects of it i like very much. It has a good energy over it. If only they would have taken more time to proper record and produce it.It sounds like it was done in a hurry and that is never a good thing.

blahblahblah · #23 Post by **blahblahblah** » Mon 10 Jul 2006, 9:27 am

Hell this is a great version! Don't compare against the original, it's not comparable. Its a completely different version. Its unashamedly big gay pop at its very best. If they had just re-done the original version exactly the same but with a different singer to Dusty, then yes, you could compare the two, but they haven't. The sound, the production, everything is different and if you take it as it is, a cheesytastic, get off your ass and dance tune, then it is fantastic!

I LOVE IT!!!!

Being boring · #24 Post by **Being boring** » Tue 11 Jul 2006, 1:40 am

It's different. It now sounds very camp... much more than usual!

You can't replace the Dusty version though, it's simply a classic.

patrick · #25 Post by **patrick** » Tue 11 Jul 2006, 3:02 am

Jareth wrote:It's strange that people hate the backing music so much, yet the incredibly dated Ressurectionist seems to popular here.

It's not that it's dated, it's that it's crap.

Remark · #26 Post by **Remark** » Tue 11 Jul 2006, 3:50 am

blahblahblah wrote:Hell this is a great version! Don't compare against the original, it's not comparable. Its a completely different version. Its unashamedly big gay pop at its very best. If they had just re-done the original version exactly the same but with a different singer to Dusty, then yes, you could compare the two, but they haven't. The sound, the production, everything is different and if you take it as it is, a cheesytastic, get off your ass and dance tune, then it is fantastic!

I LOVE IT!!!!

Completely agree! Thank you for expressing that so eloquently...! I think the song is a great driving track, especially on a gorgeous day with the windows down... LOVE the bass line too!

<remark>

gomorrah · #27 Post by **gomorrah** » Tue 11 Jul 2006, 3:52 am

I love Dusty's version.

Technotrancemix · #28 Post by **Technotrancemix** » Tue 11 Jul 2006, 1:13 pm

I think to get the best of of the track is to not compare it to the Dusty version

Bang · #29 Post by **Bang** » Wed 12 Jul 2006, 2:07 am

I like both of them for different reasons. The new production makes it into a completely different experience from the original.

Burj · #30 Post by **Burj** » Wed 12 Jul 2006, 10:05 am

the last call wrote:
Tanja wrote: It's an honor for PSB to have Elton on their records.
What kind of honor is that, if even Blue and Eminem have him.

For God's sake, this is a man (?) that's even made records with Cliff Richard and Ru Paul. PSB are hardly in esteemed company.