Page 2 of 3
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 9:11 am
by Metarakete
jasonjohn wrote: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 9:03 am
It's nice of them to say PSB can't produce a "dud disc", but they've rated a few of them 2/5 stars
Nightlight isn't a 2/5 album, imo. Over-stuffed, maybe, but not a dud.
I'd love to hear the alternative album version 'Nightlight'...
Agree with you though.
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 2:20 pm
by debbieveda
Thank you

Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 2:26 pm
by tottenhammattspurs
£1500 for the yes box set? Tell me where that one is and I’ll be buying that!!! Try doubling it!
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 4:37 pm
by y3potential
tottenhammattspurs wrote: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 2:26 pm
£1500 for the yes box set? Tell me where that one is and I’ll be buying that!!! Try doubling it!
Indeed. I too noticed the overly generous valuations for the Yes and Electric box sets..
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 5:23 pm
by negative_0ne
thanks for posting the scans.
i have some of the items on the list,
but i'm sure the pricing is conservative on a lot of them.
later
|| || | | | ||
ne g at iv e 1
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 6:27 pm
by One of the crowd
John Coleman needs to find a new job.
That discography is poorly put together with a number of errors
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 6:29 pm
by panda magic
One of the crowd wrote: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 6:27 pm
John Coleman needs to find a new job.
That discography is poorly put together with a number of errors
Not to mention that the Can You Forgive Her? promo photo is captioned as being from 2003.
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 7:32 pm
by james23_uk
Thanks for posting these
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 8:37 pm
by Pinhead44
Double post
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 8:48 pm
by Pinhead44
Pinhead44 wrote: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 8:37 pm
telys wrote: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 5:44 am
I agree completely with the short album reviews. Apart from Bilingual.
It is of course completely subjective, but I would have ratings for Release and Elysium the opposite way round (four for Release two for Elysium) an extra star on Bilingual, and a star off Introspective and Super.
And add another star to Very
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 8:56 pm
by Dieuetmondroit
Wonderful, thanks!!
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Sat 20 Apr 2024, 3:28 am
by MikeyC
neilgregory72 wrote: Thu 18 Apr 2024, 7:51 pm
Thanks for sharing.
The first issue of Record Collector I bought was #110 from October 1988 with a full PSB discography in.
That was when I first learned about all the different versions of singles they'd released. I made it my mission to seek them all out.
I've ordered this issue, 36 years after buying my first issue
You never dreamt that you would get to be
The Record Collector Magazine buyer that you always meant to be…
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Sat 20 Apr 2024, 9:54 am
by telys
petshopgrrl wrote: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 6:01 am
telys wrote: Fri 19 Apr 2024, 5:43 am
We've been around forever, look at us now together... ordering magazines online...

Oh, very good...
Yes, what is up with with that Bilingual review? How dare he suggest that "It Always Comes As A Surprise" and "To Step Aside" sound flat??
Misunderstanding the concept I think.
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Sat 20 Apr 2024, 11:27 am
by tottenhammattspurs
Nightlife suffered from multi producers making it a non cohesive listen. One eye on the musical didn’t help either.
Re: Record Collector - May 2024
Posted: Sat 20 Apr 2024, 3:07 pm
by PopKid78
jasonjohn wrote:It's nice of them to say PSB can't produce a "dud disc", but they've rated a few of them 2/5 stars
Nightlight isn't a 2/5 album, imo. Over-stuffed, maybe, but not a dud.
When Nightlife was released, John Earls reviewed it for Planet Sound, and he gave it something like 8/10. As I’ve never really been a fan of this album, this review has always been a reminder, not to get too excited when a good album review is given by a PSB fan.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk