I found the Pink Floyd part in Concrete's Luna Park

Message

diana · #1 Post by **diana** » Sun 03 Dec 2006, 7:47 pm

The solo singing part has a strong resemblance with the solo singing part in:
Great Gig In The Sky from Pink Floyd.
The song is at Dark Side of The Moon.

Bulldog · #2 Post by **Bulldog** » Sun 03 Dec 2006, 11:42 pm

I think it was actually ILTR the closest composition to Pink Floyd..It sounds almost like an outtake from "The Wall", with the horns at the beginning...

Hillbilly · #3 Post by **Hillbilly** » Mon 04 Dec 2006, 10:39 am

I hate that awful song, "The great gig in the sky". I'm not a big fan of the album itself, but that song is what really ruins it. I can stand the piano introduction but as soon as the vocalist starts to scream I most often than not skip to the next track.
And how that cut could make it onto the "Best of Pink Floyd" compilation is way beyond me...

diana · #4 Post by **diana** » Mon 04 Dec 2006, 10:55 am

Hillbilly wrote:I hate that awful song, "The great gig in the sky". I'm not a big fan of the album itself, but that song is what really ruins it. I can stand the piano introduction but as soon as the vocalist starts to scream I most often than not skip to the next track.
And how that cut could make it onto the "Best of Pink Floyd" compilation is way beyond me...

Really? I like it. Do you hear the resemblance?

The same thing you have with GGITS I have with Time. That songs starts incredible good, untill the bloke starts to sing, terrible.
On The Run is also worth listening.

Hillbilly · #5 Post by **Hillbilly** » Wed 06 Dec 2006, 8:05 am

diana wrote:
Hillbilly wrote:I hate that awful song, "The great gig in the sky". I'm not a big fan of the album itself, but that song is what really ruins it. I can stand the piano introduction but as soon as the vocalist starts to scream I most often than not skip to the next track.
And how that cut could make it onto the "Best of Pink Floyd" compilation is way beyond me...
Really? I like it. Do you hear the resemblance?

The same thing you have with GGITS I have with Time. That songs starts incredible good, untill the bloke starts to sing, terrible.
On The Run is also worth listening.

I haven't listened to the Concrete version of "Luna Park" I must add.
Yes, "On the run" is actually interesting to listen to, although it's very experimental without a tune. I like "Time" but prefer "Breathe", "Money" and "Brain damage". The rest is boring.

leesmapman · #6 Post by **leesmapman** » Wed 06 Dec 2006, 10:33 am

I like to quote the b-side of So Hard: "It must be obvious".