Page 1 of 2
"New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 5:45 pm
by Future Lover
Took me a bit to find an actual promo with "US Radio Edits" #1 and #2, which are unique yet official. Once I finally got them and compared them with everything else, turns out there's at least six different edits of this single, including a rather obscure Mexican one, which seems to be a "fixed" version of US Radio Edit #1, and best of the three variations when taking the PopArt mix into account, which seems to be the one for posterity. Anyone knows why they bothered so much with this?
Radio Edit 4:21
US Radio Edit #2 3:47
US Radio Edit 3:35
US Radio Edit #1 3:20
MX Radio Edit 3:20
PopArt Edit 3:20
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:13 pm
by Disco.
They probably thought it would be a big hit
And as it turned out it was kind of a big hit in some territories.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:14 pm
by Disco.
For instance nr#1 on the official airplay chart for 3 weeks in Denmark.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:17 pm
by Nickname
Disco. wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:13 pm
They probably thought it would be a big hit
And as it turned out it was kind of a big hit in some territories.
It's on the Top 10 of the most streamed songs from PSB.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:39 pm
by Ramzy
Future Lover wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 5:45 pm
Took me a bit to find an actual promo with "US Radio Edits" #1 and #2, which are unique yet official. Once I finally got them and compared them with everything else, turns out there's at least six different edits of this single, including a rather obscure Mexican one, which seems to be a "fixed" version of US Radio Edit #1, and best of the three variations when taking the PopArt mix into account, which seems to be the one for posterity. Anyone knows why they bothered so much with this?
Radio Edit 4:21
US Radio Edit #2 3:47
US Radio Edit 3:35
US Radio Edit #1 3:20
MX Radio Edit 3:20
PopArt Edit 3:20
What are the differences between the last three? And are the "US radio edit" versions on PopArt, Ultimate and Smash any different from each other?
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 8:24 pm
by Dreamland
I think the UK radio edit is the best version. I don’t understand why compilations have the US edit version, which misses out the ‘When evening calls…’ section. I think that’s the best bit!
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 8:53 pm
by Future Lover
Ramzy wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:39 pm
What are the differences between the last three?
Mostly around the 2:10 mark - the PopArt mix is the worst, and has a weird cut straight to the choir vocals, instead of the smooth piano breakdown compared to the other two. MX Edit and US Edit #1 are verrrrry similar, but while comparing the two, I discovered the MX Edit uses a different chorus before the piano breakdown, and it's even better. So yeah, that's the best of the three.
Ramzy wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:39 pm
And are the "US radio edit" versions on PopArt, Ultimate and Smash any different from each other?
Yep, this edit has been unchanged ever since 2003.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 8:57 pm
by Ramzy
Future Lover wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 8:53 pm
Ramzy wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:39 pm
What are the differences between the last three?
Mostly around the 2:20 mark - the PopArt mix is the worst, and has a weird cut straight to the choir vocals, instead of the smooth piano breakdown compared to the other two. MX Edit and US Edit #1 are verrrrry similar, but while comparing the two, I discovered the MX Edit uses a different chorus before the piano breakdown, and it's even better. So yeah, that's the best of the three.
Ramzy wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 6:39 pm
And are the "US radio edit" versions on PopArt, Ultimate and Smash any different from each other?
Yep, this edit has been unchanged ever since 2003.
Thanks, this is *exactly* the sort of thing I still visit the forum for. Sounds like I need to track down the Mexico radio edit!
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 9:08 pm
by Future Lover
I was a bit incorrect in my description with the differences, the Mexican edit is actually 3:50 and is similar to Edit #2. Again, the only difference is the chorus. Got them all a bit mixed up
So it's actually Edit #1 ~ PopArt Mix and Edit #2 ~ Mexico Edit.
"New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 9:40 pm
by Gabby
Leonidas wrote: Thu 31 Oct 2024, 10:05 pm
Mate, for the second day in a row, you’ve maintained your number 1 Pethead ranking!
Leonidas - how wrong you were - no way can I be the #1 Pethead.
I don't even begin to dig this deeply into the track differences.
Purchasing a teaset just ain't gonna cut it.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Sat 23 Nov 2024, 12:24 am
by glennjridge
I never thought they got the arrangement right on that one. the verse parts to me rose to the challenge and sound kind of bright lush and glorious but then when it got to the chorus it sort of lost energy and the out of place guitar riffing comes in along with the background vocals that sounded too low and dull.
I thought it could have used those bright international horn blasts you hear on Saturday night...although I know that song isnt a fave with many here.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Sat 23 Nov 2024, 12:52 am
by retrofuturist
Greetings,
Future Lover wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 9:08 pm
I was a bit incorrect in my description with the differences, the Mexican edit is actually 3:50 and is similar to Edit #2. Again, the only difference is the chorus. Got them all a bit mixed up
So it's actually Edit #1 ~ PopArt Mix and Edit #2 ~ Mexico Edit.
No worries. Thanks for explaining the differences.
Retro.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Sat 23 Nov 2024, 3:11 pm
by Disco.
Dreamland wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 8:24 pm
I think the UK radio edit is the best version. I don’t understand why compilations have the US edit version, which misses out the ‘When evening calls…’ section. I think that’s the best bit!
Neil and Chris prefer the US radio edit, to any other edit of the song,it’s mentioned in Annually.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Sat 23 Nov 2024, 3:17 pm
by VRIDD
Future Lover wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 5:45 pm
Anyone knows why they bothered so much with this?
I would say they were never satisfied with any of them.
Re: "New York City boy" - a plethora of edits
Posted: Sat 23 Nov 2024, 3:45 pm
by misterme
Disco. wrote: Sat 23 Nov 2024, 3:11 pm
Dreamland wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 8:24 pm
I think the UK radio edit is the best version. I don’t understand why compilations have the US edit version, which misses out the ‘When evening calls…’ section. I think that’s the best bit!
Neil and Chris prefer the US radio edit, to any other edit of the song,it’s mentioned in Annually.
Yeah, but I quite prefer the original UK radio edit as well. A lot is going on in this version. Just like the album version, keeping every break in its development. Just shorter.
In the US radio edit(s) it's quite straightforward and although it's even shorter than the UK version, it tends to get boring.
VRIDD wrote: Sat 23 Nov 2024, 3:17 pm
Future Lover wrote: Fri 22 Nov 2024, 5:45 pm
Anyone knows why they bothered so much with this?
I would say they were never satisfied with any of them.
This is probably the best explanation for this.
They should have asked Almighty to edit their definitive remix of the track to release it as the single version. It would have certainly been better than any of those edits.
And as it turned out it was kind of a big hit in some territories.